The Leader's Edge Article Banner

Stop Blaming Middle Management for Your Strategy's Failure

By the time of the 2015 earthquake in Nepal, I had spent much of my career as a Canadian Army logistics officer. I understood how much an operation could depend on the details that were easy to dismiss during a briefing: what had to move, when it had to arrive, and what the team on the ground would need to do its work.

I was a Major involved in planning the logistics for Operation Renaissance, Canada’s disaster-relief mission to Nepal.

We had planned the aircraft loads carefully. The forklift was assigned to the first flight because the plan depended on having it there to unload the other equipment. Without it, the crews would have a serious problem on arrival.

During a video conference shortly before departure, the Director General Operations, a senior leader I respected and had served under in Afghanistan, decided the forklift was non-essential. It was removed to make room for what he considered more critical equipment. I understood the consequence for the plan and started to speak. The senior officer beside me cut me off:

“Quiet, Major. The general made his decision.”

So the forklift stayed behind, and the aircraft left on schedule. I sat there knowing that we had made a decision about the load without accounting for what the team would need to do once it reached Nepal.

Two days later, the aircraft arrived. There was no forklift waiting. The crews spent six hours unloading equipment by hand in the heat while more aircraft circled, waiting for space on the ramp.

Eventually, the forklift was sent on a later flight and moved ahead of another aircraft. The problem was resolved, but only after it had delayed and complicated work on the ground. The after-action reports were difficult.

I have to own my part in that moment. I saw the operational problem, but I did not make sure it was heard. I confused staying quiet with showing respect for the chain of command. The decision was made above me, but that does not erase my responsibility to raise a concern clearly and professionally. Nor does it erase the organization’s responsibility to hear operational advice from the people who understand the plan.

While this was an operational decision rather than a strategic one, it illustrates a problem that extends well beyond military operations. Decisions are made at the top, important information goes unheard somewhere in the middle, and the people closest to the work are left to deal with the consequences.

When organizational strategies fail to deliver the expected results, senior leaders often question the effectiveness of their middle managers. Sometimes that criticism is warranted. But before drawing that conclusion, consider a different possibility.

What if middle management isn’t where your strategy is failing? What if it’s where the weaknesses in your strategy are becoming visible?

When middle management becomes your organizational shock absorber

Middle managers occupy one of the most challenging positions in any organization. They are responsible for translating senior leadership’s direction into operational results while maintaining the very operations they are being asked to change.

Consider an organization launching a strategic initiative to improve customer experience. The executive team announces the priority, explains its importance, and expects managers to execute.

A manager returns to their department with a different set of questions. What should the team do differently tomorrow? Which existing priorities can be adjusted? What happens when improving customer experience increases short-term costs? What decisions can the manager make independently?

Meanwhile, customers still need support, employees still need direction, and existing performance expectations remain in place.

Good managers find ways to make it work. They negotiate between departments, rearrange priorities, develop workarounds, and sometimes take on additional responsibilities themselves. Their ability to do this is valuable, but it can also create a leadership blind spot.

When capable managers repeatedly compensate for unclear direction, conflicting expectations, or inadequate resources, senior leadership may see acceptable results without understanding what it took to produce them.

The better your middle managers are at absorbing organizational friction, the easier it becomes for senior leaders to underestimate how much friction exists.

Eventually, those managers run out of capacity. Performance begins to suffer, employees become frustrated, and strategic initiatives stall. Senior leadership may then demand more accountability from the very people who have been keeping things together.

Before demanding more from your managers, understand what they have already been absorbing on your behalf.

Communicating strategy is not the same as translating it

Improving customer satisfaction, increasing profitability, and growing market share are all legitimate strategic objectives. But none of them, on its own, tells a production supervisor or sales manager how to make a decision when two of those objectives conflict.

That is where strategic translation becomes essential. Middle managers need to connect organizational objectives to departmental priorities, daily decisions, resource allocation, and performance expectations. To do that effectively, they need more than a list of tasks.

In the military, the concept of commander’s intent addresses this challenge.

No military plan can anticipate every circumstance. Information is incomplete, situations evolve, and subordinate leaders encounter problems their commanders could not have foreseen. Understanding the commander’s intent allows those leaders to exercise judgment while remaining aligned with the purpose of the operation.

It is a fundamental element of mission command, which relies on shared understanding, trust, and disciplined initiative.

Businesses are not military organizations, nor should they try to operate as such. However, the underlying leadership principle is equally relevant. Your managers need to understand what you want accomplished, why it matters, and what boundaries they must respect as they pursue it.

During the Nepal operation, the overall purpose was clear. We were deploying to deliver humanitarian assistance. The forklift was important because of the capability it provided in achieving that purpose.

When leaders evaluate individual resources, tasks, or performance measures without considering their contribution to the intended outcome, they risk improving one part of the plan at the expense of the whole.

Your managers need to influence strategy, not just receive it

Senior leaders are responsible for setting organizational direction. That does not mean they possess all the information necessary to understand the implications of their decisions.

Middle managers understand operational constraints, employee capabilities, customer expectations, and the dependencies between teams. Their experience can help senior leaders identify problems with a proposed course of action before committing the organization to it.

Unfortunately, managers are sometimes brought into the process only after decisions have been made. At that point, raising concerns can be interpreted as resistance to change rather than an attempt to improve execution.

This brings me back to that video conference before Nepal.

The general had every right to make the decision about the aircraft load. He may well have had other considerations that I was unaware of. The problem was that an important operational consequence never made it into the discussion.

Had my concern been heard, the decision might still have been the same. But we would have had an opportunity to consider how to mitigate the problem before the aircraft departed.

Seeking operational advice does not diminish a leader’s authority. It improves their ability to exercise it.

Consultation does not require consensus. Senior leaders still need to make difficult decisions, sometimes against the advice of their managers. What matters is whether they have created the conditions to make those decisions with the best available information.

The Strategy Translation Loop

Effective strategy execution is not a one-way cascade from executives to middle managers and finally to frontline employees. It requires a continuous exchange between organizational intent and operational reality.

I call this the Strategy Translation Loop, and it consists of five connected leadership activities.

1. Establish intent

Senior leaders define the desired outcome, why it matters, the conditions necessary for success, and the boundaries within which others can exercise judgment.

They must also address what happens when priorities conflict. Without that guidance, managers are left to make trade-offs that may have consequences beyond their own departments.

2. Translate

Middle managers connect the intent to the responsibilities of their teams. They determine what needs to change, how their department contributes, and what employees need to understand to make appropriate decisions.

Different departments may need to take very different actions to achieve the same organizational objective. That is often evidence of effective translation rather than a lack of alignment.

3. Validate

Managers and frontline leaders test the proposed actions against operational reality. They identify constraints, challenge assumptions, and highlight potential unintended consequences.

Senior leaders must be prepared to act on information that reveals problems requiring decisions beyond the managers’ authority. This is particularly important before significant commitments are made.

4. Execute

Frontline teams carry out the work while managers provide direction, coordination, support, and accountability. When circumstances change, people adapt within the intent and authority they have been given.

The objective is to achieve the intended outcome, not simply demonstrate compliance with the original plan.

5. Feed back

Middle managers communicate results, emerging risks, and lessons to senior leadership. Executives determine whether implementation needs adjustment, additional support is required, or an assumption behind the strategy needs reconsideration.

Their response informs the next iteration of the loop.

These activities do not need to become five additional meetings or another reporting requirement. They represent leadership responsibilities that should be embedded in how an organization already operates.

What the Strategy Translation Loop looks like in practice

Imagine a manufacturing company that wants to improve customer delivery reliability.

Sales interprets the objective as shorter delivery times and starts promising faster turnaround. Production focuses on increasing output, Supply Chain reduces inventory to lower costs, and Finance continues to push for greater operating efficiency.

Each department could be meeting its individual performance targets while the company becomes less reliable at delivering to its customers.

The managers are responding to the expectations established for them. Asking them to collaborate more effectively might help, but it will not necessarily resolve the competing performance measures driving their decisions.

Using the Strategy Translation Loop, senior leadership first clarifies what delivery reliability means. Perhaps the priority is fulfilling accurate customer commitments rather than promising the shortest possible delivery time.

Managers can then translate that intent into departmental actions. Sales commits to realistic delivery dates, Production prioritizes schedule reliability, and Supply Chain identifies which materials are critical to meeting customer commitments.

Together, they assess whether those changes are achievable and identify conflicts before implementing them. As execution progresses, they communicate results and emerging constraints back to senior leadership.

The executive team may discover that existing performance measures need to change. Reducing inventory is no longer an unconditional success if it means missing customer commitments.

Resolving that conflict is an organizational leadership responsibility. It should not be left to individual managers to manage through increasingly creative workarounds.

Middle managers are leaders, not messengers

None of this absolves middle managers of their leadership responsibilities.

If you are a middle manager, it is your responsibility to understand the intent behind organizational direction, connect it to your team’s responsibilities, and communicate concerns when you identify a problem.

That means doing more than telling your boss something will not work. Explain the consequences, identify the trade-off, and, wherever possible, offer a viable alternative. Help the decision-maker understand the issue in the context of what the organization is trying to achieve.

Looking back at Nepal, I could have done more to ensure my concern was heard. I could have found another opportunity to raise the operational implications professionally. I did not need to challenge the general’s authority to do that. I needed to exercise my own responsibility as a leader.

There will be occasions when senior leaders hear your advice and still make a decision you disagree with. Assuming the decision is ethical, lawful, and within their authority, your responsibility is to execute it professionally while continuing to provide relevant feedback.

Leadership in the middle requires the ability to influence decisions without always possessing the authority to make them. It also requires the maturity to recognize when an issue genuinely needs senior intervention and when it is yours to solve.

Find out what your managers are absorbing

If you are a senior leader concerned about strategy execution, consider having a different kind of conversation with your middle managers before reviewing another set of performance indicators.

Ask them what it actually takes to achieve the results you are seeing.

Here are five questions I would encourage you to ask:

  • What workarounds have you developed to make our current strategy work?

  • Which of our organizational priorities compete for your team’s time and resources?

  • What decisions are you being held accountable for but lack the authority to make?

  • What operational concerns have you raised that remain unresolved?

  • What would become visible to senior leadership if you stopped compensating for these problems?

That final question is particularly revealing.

Not every workaround is evidence of a leadership failure. Managers should exercise initiative, solve problems, and adapt to changing circumstances. But when the same problem repeatedly requires intervention, senior leadership needs to determine whether it is dealing with a temporary obstacle or a systemic organizational issue.

Pay attention to how you respond to the answers. If managers learn that raising problems results in their competence or commitment being questioned, they may become less willing to share the information you need.

The purpose of this conversation is not to remove accountability. It is to ensure accountability rests at the appropriate level of the organization.

Before you blame middle management, examine the conditions

My Three Domains of Leadership philosophy recognizes that leading yourself, leading your team, and leading your organization cannot be separated from one another.

It takes self-awareness to recognize when your own decisions are contributing to a problem. It takes effective team leadership to create an environment where people are comfortable raising concerns. And it takes organizational leadership to ensure that information, authority, resources, and accountability are aligned.

In Nepal, the crews on the ground spent six hours compensating for a decision made thousands of kilometres away. Their dedication helped the operation continue, but they should never have been put in that position without the operational consequences being understood.

Consider what your own people might be doing every day to compensate for decisions made elsewhere in your organization.

Their dedication may be producing the results you expect while concealing problems that you have a responsibility to address.

Before blaming middle management for failing to execute your strategy, examine whether you have established the conditions necessary for them to translate it.

Middle management should be your strategy’s greatest amplifier, not its organizational shock absorber.

If you’re experiencing a disconnect between the direction you set and the results your organization produces, let’s explore it together. Book a free Leadership Clarity Session with me, and we’ll examine what you can do as a leader to strengthen that connection.

With Insights From

One of the great benefits of hosting the Peak Performance Leadership podcast is the opportunity to learn from some incredible leadership experts. This article draws upon insights from the following guests, whose work and conversations have helped shape my thinking on strategy, organizational alignment, and execution.

Andrew Freedman

Episode 173: THRIVE with High-Performing Culture

Andrew, author of THRIVE, explores how organizational clarity, alignment, and a high-performance culture enable people to deliver meaningful results. Our conversation examines working backwards from desired outcomes and reducing the organizational friction that gets in the way of performance.

Listen to Episode 173

Sean Ryan

Episode 154: How to Get Your Business’ Strategy in Gear

Sean, author of Get in Gear, shares his Seven Gears of Execution and explains why even well-developed strategies fail to produce their intended results. We explore organizational alignment, accountability, communication, and closing the gap between strategy and execution.

Listen to Episode 154

Alex Brueckmann

Episode 311: Unlocking Winning Strategies: Aligning Culture and Leadership

Alex, author of The Strategy Legacy, examines the interconnected relationship between strategy, leadership, and organizational culture. Our conversation explores how leaders can break down organizational silos, establish shared priorities, and ensure everyone understands their contribution to the organization’s success.

Listen to Episode 311

Thank you, gentlemen, for sharing your expertise with me and the Peak Performance Leadership community.

About the Author

Scott McCarthy

Scott McCarthy is a retired Canadian Army Lieutenant-Colonel, executive leader, leadership coach, and founder of Moving Forward Leadership. During his 25-year military career, Scott led organizations responsible for complex operations, national supply-chain capabilities, and billions of dollars in assets. He now brings that experience into the private sector through his executive role with Arcanus while continuing to coach senior leaders and executives.

He is the author of You Don’t Know Sh*t About Leadership: And Neither Do I and host of the Peak Performance Leadership podcast. Scott’s work centres on the 3 Domains of Leadership: Leading Yourself, Leading Your Team, and Leading Your Organization.

FREE CHAPTER

Read the first chapter of my book free

You Don’t Know Sh*t About Leadership: And Neither Do I. Chapter one, straight to your inbox.

From Scott McCarthy, Moving Forward Leadership, Gananoque, ON K7G 2V3, movingforwardleadership.com. You’ll get a confirmation email first. No other lists unless you choose to join. Privacy Policy